1/09/2023

What Is Antenna Effect In VLSI

In this article we will discuss Antenna Effect and ways to mitigate it. Antenna Effect is a physical phenomenon and related to geometry and fabrication process of the IC. So we will start with vertical cross section of an IC. 


The above fig is showing the vertical cross section of a chip and which layer is included in which EOL.

That will help you to relate the EOLs and layers.Now lets discuss about End of Lines. 

The whole CMOS fabrication process is divided into :

i.   FEOL or Front End of Line  : 

In First End of Line we develop transistor level layout design on the wafer. The individual components like transistors , capacitors, resistors, etc.  are fabricated in the semiconductor. FEOL consist of chemical mechanical polishing a.k.a  Polarization and Cleaning of the wafer. Shallow Trench Isolation (STI) or LOCOS (tech node > 0.25 μm) comes under FEOL. FEOL also include well formation , gate module formation, Source and Drain module formation.

 ii.  MEOL or Mid End of Line   :

In Middle End of Line or MEOL we do the transistor level interconnect. MEOL consist of semiconductor wafer processing  steps that create local electrical connections among source/drain/gate of transistors. Most important part of MEOL is  gate contact formation. Most important part of MEOL is gate contact formation. It occurs after Front-End-Of-Line  (i.e transistors/design-capacitor/design-resistor formation) process are complete. Before Back-End-Of-Line metal/via/isolation-dielectric formation processes.

iii. BEOL  or Back End of Line :

In Back End of Line we do the PnR level Interconnect through Metalization/Vias including Dielectric Separators among Various Metal layers.

Antenna Effect Phenomenon :

Let's understand what is antenna effect phenomenon. Now-a-days chemical etching has been completely replaced by hot plasma-etching.Plasma related process  are used for CMOS flow for etching and deposition. The gaseous plasma contains charged particles inside. This charge gets transferred to the under-construction floating metals routes which may be connected way below up to the gate areas of MOSFET. At the same time such metals may not be connected to any  diffusion areas in the FEOL Zone. Such metal wires act as “antennas” charge receptors that pick up electrical charge from the plasma gas. Charge accumulation on the metal strip is proportional to its length.

Now lets understand the  antenna phenomenon during the process. As we can see from the above Fig,  in the substrate Source (S) , Drain (D) , STI (Shallow Trench Isolation) is formed. Gate Oxide (G) and Poly Silicon layers grown and connected to Metal layer 1(M1). After the metal deposition the layer is etched as per mask. To do that plasma is used for etching. In this gaseous environment many charge get accumulated on the top of the M1 layer. Once this amount of charges is sufficiently high it causes breakdown of Gate Oxide insulator and the charges pass on to the Silicon substrate.

Now we will dig deeper into the phenomenon and will try to understand it in a better way. Aforementioned metal  wires builds up high potential difference on the metal side through piled up charge. As a consequence high electric field builds up across the gate oxide of the Metal-Oxide-Semiconductor (MOS) structure.Sufficient  accumulation charge create a percussion path through oxide for drainage of charge. This percussion path is a small path that is created by the high amount of charge and this is just the beginning. Severe drainage in MOSFET lead to the gate oxide break-down, consequently damaging the MOSFET. On the other hand in case less  severe drainage the MOSFET is not damaged, although Hot Carrier Injection (HCI) may take place. HCI will cause faster aging and MOSFET performance will get degraded in the long run. 


Semiconductor CMOS Process :



Antenna violation occurs due to use of plasma in CMOS fabrication. SO let's take a recap of the fabrication steps. 
The fabrication process of VLSI Integrated Circuits (IC) consists of a set of basic steps  starting from crystal growth, wafer preparation, epitaxy, dielectric and poly Si film deposition, oxidation, lithography, and dry etching.  Different patterns are developed by repeating steps like deposition, photo resist coating, exposure, developing, etching, ion implantation and stripping etc as shown in the above Fig. These steps are repeated in cyclic order several times for formation of metal routes in the BEOL region. FEOL and MEOL also goes in this cyclic steps although BEOL  goes several times. The step etching is done by using plasma and  in this step antenna violation may occur. Not only 1st Metal layer, this violation may occur to any metal layer.

Different Types of Plasma Process :

There are three different plasma process involved in  VLSI

CMOS process -

1. Conductor Layer Pattern Etching Processes

2. Ashing Processes

3. Contact Etching Processes 

           

1. Conductor Layer Pattern Etching Processes : 

Etching processes splits conductor layer plates into multiple routing patterns.Here the amount of accumulated charge is proportional to the perimeter length of conductor area.  Perimeters of the spitted routing are directly exposed to plasma.

2. Ashing Processes : 

Ashing processes remove remaining photo resist layer after etching processes of conductor layer.Here the amount of accumulated charge is proportional to the area of the conductor layer patterns.   Area of conductor layer patterns is directly exposed to plasma.

3. Contact Etching Processes: 

Contact etching processes dig holes between two conductor layers. Here the amount of accumulated charge is proportional to the area of the total area of the contacts.  Here the area of all the contacts on the lower conductor layer pattern is directly exposed to plasma.

Metals/Via Stacks are built layer by layer. First, Metal1 is deposited and all unwanted portions are etched away by plasma etching. The metal geometries when they are exposed to plasma can collect charge from it. Once Metal1 is completed, Via1 is built, then Metal2 and so on. So with each passing stage,  the metal geometries can build up static electricity. If the charge collected is large enough to cause current to flow to the gate, this can cause damage to the gate oxide. Long metal lines are prone to  such failures ending into fabrication yield.


Nonuniform density of plasma across the wafer plays an important role in antenna related damage. Such non-uniformity can come from non-uniformity in radio frequency (RF) current flow, electron current flow and ion current flow. In addition to this , Electron shading effect can contribute in plasma charging. This plasma charging(metal) & discharging(through oxide) can severely degrade or destroy devices, especially Metal Oxide Semiconductor (MOS) gate dielectrics. This particular problem is becoming more prominent in lower technology node with thinner gate oxide. The gate oxide degradation occurs by Fowler-Nordheim (FN) tunnel injection between the gate oxide and the silicon substrate. 

In the continuous plasma exposure environment, the gate potential build-up adjusts itself by the  FN tunneling current. The flow of tunneling current generates trap and interface states in the gate oxide, gradually degrading the oxide quality and integrity. At very high level of stress  or prolonged exposure, it may also ultimately lead to the breakdown of the oxide. In high-aspect  ratio spaces, isotropic electrons are hindered from reaching the bottom of the space, whereas anisotropic and positively charged ions are not. This is phenomenon is called "electron shading" which happens in uniform plasma when topography exists on the wafer during plasma exposure.Insulators such as photo-resist or oxides are commonly used as masks when etching conductive films. The underlying conductor can acquire a positive charge by the electron shading mechanism.

Antenna Ratio :

The magnitude of the accumulated charge depends on the ratio of the floating conducting region area to  the gate area. This is called the Antenna Ratio and quoted in Design Rule Manual. 

The above equation shows the relationship between the antenna ratio and the current densities. A higher antenna ratio means a larger Vg and, thus more damage.

Antenna Issue Mitigation :

There are a few ways to to eliminate the antenna effect.

1. Jumper Insertion :
This is creating a metal bridge (a.k.a jumper) near gate of MOS device so that while fabrication. This jumper should take gate connections directly up to the top level metal
through stacked vias. Consequently the gate will not see any antenna due to the break-up of a long metal piece into stacked metal/via layers. The drawback is the use of stacked vias can lead to routing congestion, and hence also to an increase in die area. Stacked metal/vias may/may-not lead to EM/IR reliability issues.

2. Gate Protection Diode:
Here we connect each gate to reverse biased p-n diodes.
Using diode provides a discharge path directly to the substrate by contact to a diffusion area. If possible, these diodes are connected to gate with Metal1 so that prevention starts right with Metal1 fabrication. During normal operation this reverse biased diode will not effect functionality.
However the plasma-induced charge is discharged through the diodes, leaving gate unaffected. Drawback is usage of antenna diodes increase die area by 4-6%.

3. Embedded Protection Diode:
 Add protection diodes on every input port for every standard cell. These diodes are embedded and fixed. Hence consume unnecessary area. 

4. Diode Insertion After PnR:
Fixing only the wire with the antenna violation which will not waste routing resources. During wafer manufacturing, all the inserted diodes are floating (or ground). One diode can be used to protect all input ports that are connected to the same
output ports.



Video lecture is available here :